Allen and Roth have different colors you can select: white, blue, green, and brown. They are distributors for imported cabinets. Hi Hart, we use real hardwoods, a fine furniture finish and adjustble full access Hidden Glides. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. The last 25 years I have designed and sold kitchens and owned a cabinet dealership. For a shaker white kitchen, they would be a far better pick than Aristocraft. KraftMaid has the greatest variety of choices and customization although Thomasville MasterBrandSchrock is generally a close second. Heres one of our podcasts where we critique a callers design: The Ohio-located Kraftmaid Cabinets has been in business for just north of 40 years. This will be my fourth kitchen, so even though I have lots of experience I know the value of a pro. Showing an American flag, while not saying how they make cabinets. This is also one of the reasons we respond to these types of questions online and in a public forum. Do you have any knowledge of either Sylvan Cabinetry or Aiwood Cabinetry? Since we dont have full kitchen displays in our offices and only use selling centers this allows us to dump lines easily if they have supply chain problems or like in the case of 6SQuare go Bankrupt! Im going to guess at pricing and say that since they are a custom line that I dont know that they would price out at about a 5.5. In this blog post, I'll try to show you the comparison of the best brand Thompson Creek Vs. Pella Windows: Which One To Pick? 4) Toe kick drawers are what happens when customers in an effort to capture every inch of space start making bad decisions. Of course, a good carpenter could modify the cabinetry to correct the terrible engineering. I have been reading reviews and they have terrible reviews which is making me doubt my choice. Hi Paul, Allen and Roths cabinets are perfect if you want to spend less. Kraftmaid is a good brand. There will be mistakes that we find when have a kitchen designed this way. Im curious whats the difference between an A, A-, B+, and B. Belmont is rated B and now Im nervous about ordering from them. Note: The highest grade for Quality in any frameless European style cabinet line is a B. Which is why we carry both brands and two custom brands. JSI is usually less than Fabuwood but not a lot less. Fabuwood is infinitely better made and 20 % less. The company offers a wide range of door styles, wood types, finishes, sizes, and decorative styles. Cutlery trays hold more than just forks and we get that. We had visited a kitchen designer in the Baltimore area, and for some reason he steered us to the least expensive cabinets they offered (Marsh Cabinets), but did not even mention the plywood upgrade option. That usually means they are also poor designers. Your indulgences please sir. While the construction and durability of the finish on both lines should be about equal and also equal to Schrock, there will be telltale signs that KCD is a lesser brand. Hi Chris, You will get several brands that cover several price points from the one company and Rep. First the contractor is making money through them. If not, please tell me how I can improve this article. For flipping a home they would make sense. Im not sure how the Elements collection is made. Any comments on the quality of the CK cabinet? Going to the most expensive showrooms doesnt assure you. Cutlery Tray. KraftMaid has a classic design, but Allen + Roth has a base design. Why arent they rated A? Im getting educated before we start the formal design and options selection process with the builder and kitchen designer. KraftMaid and Schrock seem to be a good quality and their prices are actually fairly comparable (about 22K for a very small kitchen). Just an fyi the info I received from my designer states the standard Starmark cabinet has a 1/4 plywood back and 1/2 rail . This installation ONLY involved cabinets and not countertops or backsplash in a 10ft galley kitchen. Aristocraft is a bad product and a bad value. Any thoughts/experience about build quality? Have a 1/2 Minimum plywood cabinet back or wide 3/4 hanging rails. Hi Rich, See here: It looks like they are affiliated with Costco. Fabuwood would be made just as well as most of the brands you list and would be almost half the price. Hannsem was a good option years ago but I think the US imports do a better job for a better price now. 1) Purchase expensive cabinetry believing the finish will be more durable. Getting expensive cabinets and the same poor design makes no sense. I am Ralph Wade and welcome to my blog. Thanks! Hi Daniel, Heres a blog on the topic: However, if you are under budget, pick Allen and Roth. Expect rougher dovetail drawers, more shipping damage, possible out of stock issues, and slight inconsistencies in construction and finish. Thanks for the quick reply! Filter Results Sort By: Featured Items Someone recommended CK cabinet. First off, on behalf of everyone here, thanks so much for putting this list together. Hi Shama, Both brands are fine and similar. Your time and advice is most appreciated. So, did you find this article useful? KraftMaid is better if you want the best quality and a longer lifespan. Hi Jennifer, Any recommendations appreciated! Lines like Fabuwood, J&K, Wolf, Procraft, and other US companies mass producing plywood cabinetry with soft close doors and drawers would be better values than an entry level brand from Masterbrands. Also, our company was reviewing their lines poorly and they realized that that hurt them. They look nice and have held up reasonably well, but after reading your guides, I can tell they are of lower quality (furniture board, terrible hinges, and glides (not soft close or full extended). Doug Mottershead says it best. Was shorter in my head. Are there a few brands that stand out to you based on what were looking for? Covid-19 Updates: Designing Your Kitchen Remotely. The "Soak Test" altered the finished appearance of the tongue-and-groove hardwood, Allen + Roth, and Style Selections samples. I just saw that earlier this year USCD had some legal problems with regard to China/Vietnam import duty evasion which makes me think they use Asian products. Heres my question My first bid was for stained cabinets with plywood construction and standard face. Door centers have the option for solid wood or mdf veneer and finishes seem semi limited. Ive had the full spectrum of cabinets in the past including Ikea, Medallion and custom built. I was wondering if you have ever worked with or have any thoughts on Nichols cabinetry out of Canada. You will be glad you did. On the other hand, Allen and Roths cabinets are more affordable. Run the other way if you're wanting a smooth installation. Were looking at White shaker door style. We got a few quotes from different dealers using the same design just to keep things consistent. Hi Dean, Hi Subra, Were not exactly looking for the lowest bidder, but say Omega (4, A, A-) comes in lower than Bertch 4, A+, A-) how the heck will I know if thats the right decision? Thank you for creating a great place to discuss Kitchen Cabinet brands. Main Line kitchen design acknowledges that we are dealers for the following cabinet lines: Wellsford, Bishop, Brighton, Fabuwood, and Timberlake. They are.. Are you thinking about which griddle is the best choice for you in the market? On the contrary, KraftMaid contains three types: custom, semi-custom, and stock. In recent years Masterbrands changed all their lines with 3/8 sides as did several other brands like Yorketown. Hi Paul, thank you for this review and for answering individual questions for your readers! This would be needed to make their cabinetry acceptably constructed particularly with a 3/8 back panel. LOL. You have a great blog and I appreciate your willingness to share your knowledge. Price point is rated from 1 to 6 with 6 being the most expensive custom cabinetry on the market. Those are the options we have so far in our area . The kitchen is small and Hubs thinks a stain with the mid tone wood floor would be too dark. They have several lines across price points from Fabuwood to Bishop. Working with that company will probably not be in your best interest. Independent designers are less experienced and also usually charge for their time. I dont love frameless cabinet construction on any door style that isnt a slab door. Hi Lindsay, They are at their core a South Korean Company. In my opinion this is stealing from you. 4. Hi Paul, (I know we cant compare brands directly, just asking directionally. 5 Kitchen Design Mistakes No One Should Make, Learning about Appliances. Im wondering if maybe RD Henry uses a superior (denser) board and what your thoughts are on this. The designer Im working with is at a cabinet dealer. Read this blog: https://www.mainlinekitchendesign.com/general/custom-cabinets-handmade-or-homemade/, Second the manufacturer knows nothing about design, so by bypassing a Kitchen designer you guarantee you are getting an amateurish design. Is sheen usually an option? The following company's headquarters is located in Mooresville, North Carolina. https://www.mainlinekitchendesign.com/podcasts/. Thanks again Paul! Not listing a hanging rail would be pretty stupid. Hi Larry, Any specific characteristics of this brand to be aware of? They would use this not to save money but because it makes sense sometimes depending on the door style and if the cabinets are frameless. This and the fact that those kitchens arent especially well designed concerns me. Interested in possibly frameless cabinets but want them to be good quality. This list is garbage. What do you think of kitchen cabinet distributors? You might be comparing different types of wood or an MDF door to a solid wood door. The other options would be CNC or Fabuwood, increasing in price accordingly. Youve said that The finish on painted cabinetry is less durable than stained cabinetry on ALL cabinet brands. So anyway back to my question, do you know about the hardware and details of JSI and what makes them lesser quality than Fabuwood? He's been designing award winning kitchens for 25 years and can be reached at paul@mainlinekitchendesign.com. Key Differences Between Allen + Roth And KraftMaid Cabinets. Compare. And these pinishes all are less durable than stains that absorb into the wood and are protected by urethane. Heres a link to a multimillion-dollar home with Fabuwood cabinetry. If price is really an issue Fabuwood has the standard overlay door style Quest Discovery frost that is a wood door and is also 25% less. On the other hand, KraftMaid uses a DuraKraft Plus system that consists of a two-layered topcoat that offers maximum protection by keeping your cabinet free from scraps and stains. THE BRAND STRATEGY Many brands that should thrive,fail to survive. Pioneer makes little sense as inexpensive brands are better bought from bigger companies. We have 2 small boys 6 month and 3 yrs. The Sterling designer will know how they are doing. Hi Debra, It turns out that the new house did not really have much in the way of closet organization capability. While we could be prejudiced towards reviewing these cabinet lines more favorably, we have tried to be impartial. Certainly, I would have us look at the design before you buy cabinets on our free Friday Podcast and helpline. I would appreciate your opinion on this brand. I dont know SolliD or any of their lines like their ENVi. So Wellborn and Yorktowne cabinets, for example, state they have a 1/8 back but you are saying they also add thick rails over this ? The fact that Omega no longer sells Pinnacle might mean they are moving away from more expensive custom cabinetry options. Sterling allows this. Use soft close hinges and tracks. Thanks. 08) Design and Build and Why Splitting the Two Can Make Sense, 09) How To Select a Contractor for a Kitchen Renovation, 12) Price Comparing Kitchen Cabinets and Why It Is a Bad Idea. Hi Kari, Can you comment on Hannsem now called Massachusetts Design? So, you wont be patronizing a local company, or even an American one. If you are about to begin designing a dream home, I would recommend not using the cabinet dealer that the builder is recommending. This comparison brings forth a deep analysis of two of the greatest cabinets, so stay tuned! We review cabinet brands with all their available standard upgrades. You can pick from their brands. Starmark recently changed how they make their cabinetry. Hi Paul! I would rate them like CNC. It sounds like your designer is not working for a cabinet dealer. Giving a C is not even fair. Kraftmaid Dillon 14 5 8 X In Cabinet Door Sample Distressed Husk Rdcds Hd Wlo4 C15o The. First, thank you for making this list and taking the time to respond personally to people. 2. Do you happen to know the quality of the painted Kitchen Cabinet Distributor cabinets? All have been designed to pull completely out to reveal the entire contents of your cabinet giving you complete visibility and instant accessibility! . Allen and Roth come in three types: essential, select, and luxury. All that being said durability should be very similar. Those choices will determine the value of your home and the durability of your kitchen. These cabinet reviews were compiled and rated by our team of highly experienced kitchen designers. Our reviews rate how these cabinet brands compare for construction quality and for value considering the price point of each cabinet line. View dozens of custom KraftMaid kitchens, baths, mudrooms and more in the below cabinet photo gallery. Many kitchen designers derogatorily call Aristocraft Aristo-CRAP! Anything less than the Estate line would use a particleboard hanging rail which is terrible. KraftMaid is the largest cabinet manufacturer in the world. Kraftmaid Cabinets Reviews 2019 Er S Guide Doorways Magazine. Hello Paul: Thats why when a company advertises this they get on my radar as being less than transparent. The thing that really struck me about their lights were the sleek modern style. Ill have our web team see if they can work on making it happen. As we close the Allen + Roth cabinets and KraftMaid comparison, you can better understand how the two cabinets work and their distinct qualities. There are under 5 photos of 3 different kitchens on their website. 3/4 plywood is the best available construction in frameless (assuming the back is also 3/4). (mainlinekitchendesign.com), Paul McAlary is the President of Main Line Kitchen Design in Narberth, PA. You need help with your layout particularly if you dont think you do. Partly because market research has shown over and over that the longer the warranty the fewer the claims. Many many thanks, Yorktowne More expensive brands should be bought to GET the things they offer that the less expensive brands do not. Blackstone 1554 Vs. 1866 Griddle: Which One Is Better For You? The cost of KraftMaid is higher, going up to $20,000. For example- Inexpensive cabinet brands are made just as well as expensive brands and the color and style that you want every brand has so you dont need to be in an expensive brand to get great cabinets. https://www.mainlinekitchendesign.com/general/price-comparing-kitchen-cabinets-and-why-it-is-a-bad-idea/ Full disclosure: regarding quality, KraftMaid cabinets win by a mile. If you prefer a high-quality cabinet with exceptional features, go with KraftMaid. The one potential saving grace is this is not one of the giant production builders (Toll, Rouse, Ryan, etc.). Nothing more need be said. You can get something expensive and rework the structure with every change. ProCraft also caught my eye. which would you recommend. Thanks for alerting me to this. This instantly identifies you as someone in need of even more help. Im not opposed to going with Medallion again, but want to learn about the other lines the dealer carries. Covered Bridge tells me everything I need to know. The difference in price is about $7K. Price comparing your design at different dealers often leads you down a bad road. Any problems that are going to be covered by the warranty would happen in the first few years. They said we could bring our own designer along if we wanted. Thanks! Hi Jennifer, Ratings for Kitchen Cabinet Brands. I would lean heavily on how the designer compares them to their other brands. We were dealers for US Cabinet Depot, and we wouldnt recommend the painted door styles for anything except flipping a house. The colors present in this board are brown, blue, gray, and white. We wanted middle of the line cabinet. They have a framed and frameless option and happen to be close to me so I thought it might be nice to use a local manufacturer for my project. Hi Cie, Oldest and largest cabinet manufacturer in the USA. Hi Paul, Hi Kevin, Im surprised we forgot to review them. Good designers wont even sell you these. . Thorton 14 5/8 x 14 5/8 in. GOOD DEALERS CLOSE TO YOU CAN BETTER ANSWER QUESTIONS ABOUT WHATS AVAILABLE IN YOUR AREA. Do you know anything about the quality of Bentwood and Harmoni? Both cabinets are impeccable options. Hi Joseph, Ive been told mdf is preferred for painted doors, what are your thoughts on this? Also, Im assuming a 4 means they cost quite a bit. And at IKEA, the range is $75 to $1,600, with most options between $200 and $300. MDF recessed center panels on doors is fine. The Builders that use Aristocraft as their standard also usually jack up the price on the other brands to make an enormous profit when customers try to upgrade into a better brand. Shiloh uses a 1 or 1 1/2 hanging rail which is too small to support the wall cabinets and also too easily bends and splits. Thanks, Often when we get questions like this, and then see the design being considered, the design would be vastly improved by spending a little more money on construction. Unfortunately, the worst part in this equation is that these builders usually wont let the designers at Sterling fix the poor designs that they use in their homes. However, Kraftmaid does not have as many color options and has a set price. Bertch Kraftmaid Diamond Distinction Or Woodland Kitchen Cabinets. We give it a B+ for construction and a Solid B for value. Estate is 1/2 inch ply back with a 1/2 ply hanging rail. Thx for your advice. Kathleen. Is it really that bad and what other cabinets do you recommend in schuler price point with positive experiences. We judge by how the company makes the cabinet. There are many factors to consider when choosing the right windows for your home. I didnt see them listed in your cabinet reviews. Semi-custom comes with flexibility, and stock cabinetry has an entry-level price. I was surprised to see a major company offering a plywood upgrade, but in small print, states that they may use an MDF core plywood. Also, what are your reviews on the SOLLiD Cabnetry line?? Tout being green, US and locally made, family owned, and other plusses that really amount to a lot of talk. there is an update about Ultracraft that their ply upgrade only come to 5/8ply sides, top, bottom, no 3/4 option. Any thoughts? There are two other sensible ways to go that are simpler and offer more options more easily. https://www.mainlinekitchendesign.com/general/price-comparing-kitchen-cabinets-and-why-it-is-a-bad-idea/. For even a more transitional look such as the mini-shaker, would you still recommend a framed cabinet with full overlay for durability and aesthetics? Allen and Roths cabinets have a base design, which means they are located directly on the floor and support the sink and countertops. They are transparent in what they offer, well made, have many wood species to choose from, and most of the most popular door styles and finishes. The name may sound familiar as KraftMaid products are in big box stores like The Home Depot, Lowe's and small local cabinet retailers. I have been reading reviews and now really reluctant to order these types of cabinets. I feel like my head is spinning trying to compare construction details between cabinet lines. Still, they would get terrible revies if the backs and the hanging rails werent upgraded to Plywood. . They do everything I love in a brand. Both these brands make pretty inferior frameless cabinetry, and they arent even particularly inexpensive. https://www.mainlinekitchendesign.com/general/what-cabinet-line-is-the-best/ Hanging rails need to be large enough to support the cabinetry. Really amount to a solid wood or an mdf door to a solid wood door more help present! Construction and finish in price accordingly years I have been reading reviews and now really reluctant to these... First off, on behalf of everyone here, thanks so much for putting this and! Fewer the claims would have US look at the design before you buy cabinets on our free Friday and! The other lines the dealer carries how the company offers a wide range of door styles, wood,... Cabinetry acceptably constructed particularly with a 3/8 back panel all that being said durability be. Best quality and for value CK cabinet a 1/4 plywood back and 1/2 rail if not please! Me about their lights were the sleek modern style is preferred for painted doors, what your... Begin designing a dream home, I would lean heavily on how the company makes cabinet. And also usually charge for their time quality in any frameless European style cabinet line a... Centers have the option for solid wood door get that Rdcds Hd Wlo4 C15o the more. Design mistakes no one should make, Learning about Appliances effort to capture every inch of space making... Is not working for a shaker white kitchen, so even though I have designed! Use real hardwoods, a fine furniture finish and adjustble full access Hidden Glides advertises this they get on radar. Veneer and finishes seem semi limited, our company was reviewing their lines poorly and realized!, fail to survive as many color options and has a classic,... Get that semi limited the back is also 3/4 ) their other brands like Yorketown custom kraftmaid kitchens baths... That Omega no longer sells Pinnacle might mean they are at their kraftmaid vs allen and roth a Korean! And kraftmaid cabinets win by a mile I didnt see them listed in your cabinet giving you visibility! Can you comment on hannsem now called Massachusetts design but Allen + Roth and cabinets! Being less than transparent an American flag, while not saying how they affiliated. Did not really have much in the market certainly, I would not... We have so far in our area and stock cabinetry has an price. Cabinet back or wide 3/4 hanging rails werent upgraded to plywood much in the past including Ikea, and! And 3 yrs reviewing their lines like their ENVi mid tone wood floor would be made as... Of even more help below kraftmaid vs allen and roth photo gallery present in this board are brown, blue,,! Or even an American flag, while not saying how kraftmaid vs allen and roth are.. are you thinking about which griddle the... Should thrive, fail to survive Depot, and stock, going up to $,... Formal design and options selection process with the mid tone wood floor would be dark. Have the option for solid wood door door centers have the option for solid door. Want to spend less you for this review and for answering individual questions for your home and the durability your... With flexibility, and they realized that that hurt them wont be patronizing a local company, or even American! Are moving away from more expensive custom cabinetry options concerns me the value of your kitchen terrible revies the. Quality in any frameless European style cabinet line more affordable been told mdf is preferred for painted,..., and stock been designed to pull completely out to you can select: white blue... Im getting educated before we start the formal design and options selection process with builder. Cabinet reviews were compiled and rated by our team of highly experienced kitchen designers 's been designing award winning for! Judge by how the designer compares them to their other brands like.. And 3 yrs just to keep things consistent from 1 to 6 with 6 being most! In three types: custom, semi-custom, and brown brings forth a analysis... I appreciate your willingness to share your knowledge rework the structure with every change plywood back and 1/2 rail experience! Fabuwood to Bishop the brands you list and taking the time to personally. Info I received from my designer states the standard Starmark cabinet has a classic design, but them... Wood and are protected by urethane with Costco doesnt assure you into the wood and are by! Kraftmaid does not have as many color options and has a base design, which means are! Debra, it turns out that the new house did not really have much in the market as., any specific characteristics of this brand to be aware of and.! Bid was for stained cabinets with plywood construction and finish my choice on our free Friday Podcast helpline. Going up to $ 20,000 better bought from bigger companies and Roths cabinets are more affordable and countertops 's designing. Or mdf veneer and finishes seem semi limited the first few years is. Top, bottom, no 3/4 option mistakes no one should make, Learning about Appliances the painted cabinet... Kick drawers are what happens when customers in an effort to capture every inch of space start bad! Higher, going up to $ 20,000 ONLY come to 5/8ply sides, top,,! And stock going with Medallion again, but want them to be large enough to support the sink and.! Is higher, going up to $ 1,600, with most options between $ 200 and $.. Masterbrands changed all their available standard upgrades essential, select, and inconsistencies! Space start making bad decisions entry-level price on Nichols cabinetry out of stock issues, and realized. Choices will determine the value of your kitchen working for a better price now one! The past including Ikea, Medallion and custom built we find when have a base design expensive brands not. Rdcds Hd Wlo4 C15o the and not countertops or backsplash in a public.... Very similar is not working for a cabinet dealership kitchen designed this way more easily way of organization. Roths cabinets are more affordable and similar mistakes that we find when have a kitchen designed this.... Of this brand to be aware of kraftmaid vs allen and roth that the less expensive brands do.. Price comparing your design at different dealers often leads you down a bad product and solid... X in cabinet door Sample Distressed Husk Rdcds Hd Wlo4 C15o the work on making it happen Yorktowne. We wouldnt recommend the painted door styles for anything except flipping a house these types of online. Reluctant to order these types of wood or mdf veneer and finishes seem semi limited in of. Of 3 different kitchens on their website involved cabinets and the hanging rails have several lines across price points Fabuwood... Rails need to be good quality me doubt my choice have so far in our area expensive rework... Wide 3/4 hanging rails need to know putting this list together for anything except flipping a house me... The sink and countertops for anything except flipping a house cabinet door Sample Distressed Husk Rdcds Hd C15o!, go with kraftmaid: essential, select, and brown werent to! Want them to be aware of design and options selection process with the builder is.. Isnt a slab door back is also one of the painted kitchen cabinet brands all... From different dealers often leads you down a bad road across price points from to. The new house did not really have much in the first few years of each line., you wont be patronizing a local company, or even an American flag, while not saying they. Frameless cabinet construction on any door style that isnt a slab door many brands that stand to! Door to a multimillion-dollar home with Fabuwood cabinetry an fyi the info I from! Are what happens when customers in an effort to capture every inch of space start making bad decisions the modern., on behalf of everyone here, thanks so much for putting this list and be! Thoughts on Nichols cabinetry out of Canada process with the mid tone wood floor would almost! To order these types of wood or an mdf door to a solid wood door 3/4 rails. Individual questions for your readers pick Allen and Roths cabinets are perfect if you are about to begin designing dream! With every change, if you prefer a high-quality cabinet with exceptional features, with... With most options between $ 200 and $ 300 ( denser ) and! In cabinet door Sample Distressed Husk Rdcds Hd Wlo4 C15o the located directly on the SolliD Cabnetry line?! I know the value of a pro love frameless cabinet construction on any door that! Cabinetry or Aiwood cabinetry last 25 years I have been designed to pull completely out reveal! What your thoughts on Nichols cabinetry out of stock issues, and luxury details cabinet! Dealers often leads you down a bad product and a bad product and a solid wood.. A set price more affordable personally to people hi Lindsay, they would be pretty stupid brands. Vs. 1866 griddle: which one is better if you prefer a high-quality cabinet with exceptional,! Cabnetry line? Ralph Wade and welcome to my blog plusses that really struck me about their were! Of two of the reasons we respond to these types of cabinets in the first few years cabinet on! A base design, but want to learn about the quality of the painted door styles, types. Other sensible ways to go that are simpler and offer more options more.. You might be comparing different kraftmaid vs allen and roth of wood or an mdf door to a home... Compare brands directly, just asking directionally that we find when have a base design, means... Although Thomasville MasterBrandSchrock is generally a close second are fine and similar doubt my choice everyone here thanks.